Crime
36-year-old Justin Mattingly killed after shooting outside QuikTrip gas station in Tulsa
Tulsa, OK – September 21, 2025 – The Tulsa Police Department is investigating a deadly shooting that occurred late Sunday night in the parking lot of a QuikTrip gas station, located at 220 N. Gilcrease Museum Road.
At approximately 11:20 p.m., officers responded to multiple reports of gunfire at the location.
Upon arrival, they discovered 36-year-old Justin Mattingly suffering from a gunshot wound to the head.
Despite lifesaving efforts, Mattingly succumbed to his injuries within minutes.
According to investigators, the shooting stemmed from an altercation between Mattingly and another man.
Surveillance video reviewed by detectives showed the dispute beginning inside the convenience store, where the suspect was seen assaulting Mattingly, who in turn made verbal threats.
The confrontation later spilled into the parking lot. A short time after the initial incident, Mattingly and a friend—both riding motorcycles—pulled up alongside the suspect’s vehicle at a gas pump.
Detectives say Mattingly kicked the suspect’s car door before beginning to ride away.
At that moment, the suspect, still seated in his vehicle, fired a single shot, striking Mattingly in the head.
The alleged shooter was detained and questioned by police but has since been released.
Authorities emphasized that no arrest has been made at this stage of the investigation.
Due to the complexity of the case, detectives are compiling all evidence and witness statements for submission to the Tulsa County District Attorney’s Office, which will ultimately determine whether criminal charges are filed.
The investigation remains active.
MT. JULIET, Tenn. — Authorities have identified two victims killed during an active shooter incident at Cedar Creek Marina in Mt. Juliet late Friday night.
The suspect, identified as Gary Haley, a convicted felon with an extensive criminal history, is deceased following an officer-involved shooting, officials confirmed.
Mount Juliet Police officers were dispatched at approximately 9:30 p.m. Friday to the Cedar Creek Marina, located in the 9000 block of Saundersville Road, after receiving reports of a man threatening another individual on the docks.
Due to the active shooter report, a shelter-in-place order was issued for the surrounding area as a precaution.
Upon arrival, officers located an adult male suffering from a gunshot wound.
The victim was later identified as Robby Brogdon, who was transported to a local hospital for emergency medical treatment.
Despite life-saving efforts, Brogdon later succumbed to his injuries.
Investigators determined that the suspected shooter had retreated to a boat within the marina and had barricaded himself inside.
The standoff continued for several hours as officers secured the scene and attempted to resolve the situation safely.
At approximately 1:00 a.m. Saturday, the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation (TBI) reported that the suspect engaged responding officers and fired shots at them under circumstances that remain under investigation. Officers returned fire.
The suspect, Gary Haley, was later found deceased aboard the vessel.
During the course of the response, officers also discovered a second adult male victim, Nathan Jones, who had been shot by the suspect.
Jones was pronounced dead at the scene.
No law enforcement officers were injured during the incident.
The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation has assumed responsibility for the investigation, which includes a homicide, an attempted homicide, and an officer-involved shooting.
TBI agents are actively conducting interviews, collecting evidence, and working to establish a comprehensive timeline of events.
Upon completion of the investigation, findings will be submitted to 15th Judicial District Attorney General Jason Lawson for review.
Authorities stated that additional information will be released as it becomes available.