Crime
Kayla Noel Day, girlfriend of Luke Daley Arrested in Connection to the Disappearance of Nancy Guthrie
TUCSON, Ariz. — Developments continue in the ongoing investigation into the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, as law enforcement activity and related arrests have drawn increased public attention.
Arrest of Kayla Noel Day
According to publicly available jail records, Kayla Noel Day was arrested late on the evening of February 12, 2026, at approximately 11:00 p.m.
She is currently listed as being held in the Pima County Jail.
As of this writing, official booking details regarding specific charges have not been publicly confirmed.
Day is identified as the girlfriend of Luke Anthony Daley, who was detained the following day, February 13, 2026, during a SWAT operation at a residence in the 6200 block of North Placita de Rojelio in Tucson.
Public records indicate that Day has prior arrests dating back to 2011, including cases involving burglary, drug-related offenses, and stolen property.
Court documentation shows multiple prior law enforcement contacts over the past decade. Authorities have not stated whether her current detention is directly connected to the Nancy Guthrie investigation.
SWAT Operation and Vehicle Towing
On February 13, a significant law enforcement operation unfolded at a residence believed to be associated with Luke Anthony Daley, 37. The operation involved SWAT personnel and resulted in multiple individuals being detained. Daley’s brother, Matthew Daley, 39, was also reportedly detained at the scene.
The residence is publicly listed as being owned by Mary C. Daley. Officials have not confirmed whether any arrests stemming from that operation are directly tied to the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie.
During and after the operation, vehicles connected to the property were towed. A vehicle with apparent front-end damage had been observed parked in the driveway prior to its removal. Authorities later towed a second vehicle from the same residence.
Around the same timeframe, FBI agents stopped and processed a silver Range Rover approximately two miles from Nancy Guthrie’s residence. The vehicle was later towed after agents examined its contents. Public vehicle records indicate the Range Rover was reportedly sold on February 13, 2026. Federal authorities have not confirmed whether the vehicle is directly connected to the disappearance, stating only that investigative leads are being pursued.
DNA Evidence and Forensic Testing
Sheriff Chris Nanos of the Pima County Sheriff’s Department addressed media reports suggesting the abduction may have stemmed from a burglary.
He stated:
“That did not come from us. We have no idea where that information originated, and even though that may be one of many possibilities, we would never speculate publicly. We will allow the evidence to guide us to a motive.”
Gloves discovered approximately two miles from the Guthrie residence were collected and shipped overnight on February 12 to a private forensic laboratory in Florida, where they arrived February 13 for analysis.
Preliminary DNA results were received February 14 by the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Officials are awaiting final quality control confirmation before entering an unidentified male DNA profile into CODIS, the Bureau’s national Combined DNA Index System database. The upload process typically takes approximately 24 hours once verification is complete.
Investigators collected approximately 16 gloves in total from areas near the residence. Most were determined to belong to volunteer searchers. However, one glove reportedly containing an unidentified male DNA profile appeared distinct and consistent with gloves worn by a masked individual captured in surveillance footage the night of Nancy’s disappearance.
The FBI has confirmed that DNA recovered from Nancy Guthrie’s property does not match her or individuals known to be in close contact with her. The origin of the DNA remains under investigation.
Surveillance Footage and Additional Evidence
The FBI released surveillance video from Nancy’s Nest doorbell camera showing a masked individual wearing nitrile gloves approaching her home the evening she disappeared. The individual appeared to inspect the camera and attempt to obscure its view with flowers.
Because there was no paid Nest subscription associated with the account, investigators reportedly worked with Google to retrieve stored footage from server backups.
A forensic sketch was later produced by Lois Gibson of Houston based on the limited facial features visible in the footage. Only portions of the eyes and partial facial structure could be inferred.
Authorities have also confirmed that Nancy’s pacemaker — capable of syncing with her iPhone and Apple Watch — stopped transmitting data at approximately 2:30 a.m. on the morning of her disappearance. Specialized equipment was installed on a sheriff’s helicopter to attempt to detect radio-frequency signals associated with the device. Officials have not disclosed whether those efforts produced actionable results.
Additional Context and Public Clarifications
Earlier scanner traffic incorrectly linked the SWAT operation to the residence of County Attorney Baird Greene. The Sheriff’s Office later clarified that the targeted residence was a different nearby property.
Earlier in the week, Tucson resident Carlos Palazuelos was detained but later released without charges after investigators determined he was not connected to the case.
The FBI has increased the reward for information leading to an arrest in the disappearance to $100,000.
Several ransom-style communications demanding up to $6 million have reportedly been sent to media outlets; however, law enforcement has not verified their authenticity. Deadlines referenced in those communications have passed without confirmation of legitimacy.
Ongoing Investigation
Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance has drawn national attention, in part because she is the mother of Savannah Guthrie, co-anchor of NBC’s Today show. Family members have described the situation as emotionally devastating.
Authorities emphasize that the investigation remains active and that no conclusions regarding motive or direct involvement of any specific individual have been publicly confirmed. Both local and federal agencies continue to coordinate investigative and forensic efforts.
Officials have stated they will release additional information when appropriate, while withholding certain details to preserve the integrity of the investigation.
The search for Nancy Guthrie remains ongoing.
PAWTUCKET, R.I. — A source familiar with the situation told Channel2 NOW that the individual responsible for the shooting at the ice rink is the father of a North Providence High School senior.
The source stated they previously played hockey with one of the suspect’s sons, who was reportedly among those targeted during the incident.
According to the source, the suspect fatally shot his young daughter and opened fire on his ex-wife and another individual during his son’s Senior Night hockey game.
Authorities have not publicly confirmed these specific details, and the identities of those involved have not yet been officially released.
A tragic act of domestic violence unfolded Monday afternoon at Lynch Arena in Pawtucket, where the father of a North Providence High School senior allegedly shot five members of his own family during a Senior Night hockey game.
Two victims died as a result of the shooting, and three others were critically injured before the gunman took his own life, according to multiple sources with direct knowledge of the investigation.
The incident occurred at approximately 2:30 p.m. during a Senior Night matchup featuring the Coventry-Johnston cooperative hockey team against the Blackstone Valley Schools team, which includes St. Raphael Academy, Providence Country Day School, and the public school districts of North Providence and North Smithfield.
The event had drawn dozens of students, parents, and community members to celebrate graduating seniors.
According to sources, the student’s mother was fatally shot at the rink. A sibling later succumbed to injuries at the hospital.
Three additional family members were transported to Rhode Island Hospital in critical condition. A spokesperson for Brown Health confirmed their status as of late Monday afternoon. Authorities have not released the names of the victims.
Video from a livestream of the game shows the moment violence erupted.
The footage captures the sound of rapid gunfire interrupting play on the ice, apparently originating from the stands.
At least 14 shots can be heard fired in quick succession, followed by one or two additional gunshots roughly 10 seconds later.
Players and spectators are seen scrambling off the ice and fleeing the seating area in panic.
The shooting prompted a massive law enforcement response. Police vehicles quickly surrounded the arena, and officers secured the scene.
Shortly afterward, numerous hockey players were seen gathered outside the facility—some still in socks after removing their skates—before being transported from the area for safety.
Pawtucket Mayor Don Grebien described the shooting as a tragic and devastating event.
“What should have been a joyful occasion, with dozens of families, students, and supporters gathered to celebrate Senior Night, was instead marked by violence and fear,” Grebien said in a statement. He characterized the shooting as an isolated incident and expressed condolences to the victims and their families.
“Pawtucket is a strong and resilient community, but tonight we are a city in mourning,” he added. “We will stand together to support all those affected in the difficult days ahead.”
Rhode Island Governor Dan McKee also issued a statement, encouraging anyone in need of mental health assistance to contact 988 and announcing that additional counseling resources would be made available to affected students and families.
“Our state is grieving again,” McKee said. “As governor, a parent, and a former coach, my heart breaks for the victims, families, students, and everyone impacted by the devastating shooting at Lynch Arena in Pawtucket.”
Kash Patel, Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, confirmed that agents from the FBI’s Boston Division responded to Pawtucket and are assisting in the investigation. He stated that federal authorities would provide any necessary resources to state and local law enforcement.
School officials moved quickly to reassure families. Providence Country Day School Head of School Kevin Folan informed families that all PCD students, parents, and staff who attended the game were safe. Johnston school officials similarly confirmed that all of their students were accounted for.
Coventry Superintendent Don Cowart sent updates throughout the afternoon, first confirming that all district students had been accounted for and later announcing that they had been reunited with their families. He noted that mental health resources would be made available to hockey players and their families in the days ahead.
Authorities continue to investigate the circumstances surrounding the shooting, including the events leading up to the violence and the suspect’s actions inside the arena. Officials have emphasized that this appears to have been a targeted domestic incident rather than a broader threat to the public.
Further details are expected to be released as the investigation progresses.